This is the most infamous season in the history of baseball. The Chicago White Sox won the pennant, then lost to the Cincinnati Reds in the World Series. Later, it was revealed that eight members of the White Sox had accepted money from gamblers to intentionally lose the Series. It became the worst scandal in baseball history.
        The complete story of the Black Sox scandal would require a novel, so I'll focus on just a couple of subjects. To save the game's integrity, the owners hired Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis as the first Commissioner of Baseball. Landis banned all eight players for life, including superstar "Shoeless" Joe Jackson.

Offensive Positions (LF, CF, RF, 1B)
   AVGOBASLUABHIT DB TP HR RUN RBI BB SB OPS
LF B RUTH BOS 322456657 432139341229103114101 7 1114
CF T COBB DET 384429515 4971913613 1 92 70 3828 944
LF J JACKSON CHI351422506 5161813114 7 79 96 60 9 928
LF B VEACH DET 355398519 5381914517 3 87101 3319 916
1B G SISLER STL 352390530 511180311510 96 83 2728 921
RF H HEILMANN DET 320366477 5371723015 8 74 93 37 7 843
CF T SPEAKER CLE 296395433 4941463812 2 83 63 7315 828
     

         Most people have heard of Joe Jackson, and you may even have an opinion on his guilt. He was a great player, and would be in the Hall Of Fame had he not been banished from the game. A lot of people think he should be in the Hall, that he really had nothing to do with the game fixing (as evidence, they point to his .375 batting average in the Series; he was the best hitter on either team). The movie Field Of Dreams portrays Jackson as an innocent and heroic figure (they also portray him as a right-handed hitter, but never mind that).
        There are two problems with the pro-Jackson argument. One, he knew about the conspiracy, and sat in on the secret meetings. Two, he accepted money from the gamblers. These facts were admitted in court, and provide a strong case that he should have been banned. What evidence is there that he deserved leniency?
        The good batting average? Not in my books. There are many ways to lose a ballgame, such as throwing a ball to the wrong base or not breaking up a double play, or whatever. Jackson's batting average is not grounds for a complete acquittal. Maybe he just picked his spots; half of Jackson's RBI (and his only home run) came in the final game, when his team was already losing 10-1.
         The only pro-Jackson argument I can accept is that Jackson, though he took the gamblers' money, only did so because (to be brutally honest) he was dumber than a bag of rocks and didn't know what he was getting involved with. He probably played to win, because it was the only way he knew how to play. He just got himself into an unfortunate situation he couldn't get out of.
        This argument probably has some merit; Jackson was illiterate, and I don't think he had much street sense, either. But I think it's a poor excuse. I'm sympathetic towards Jackson, but rules are rules, and he broke them in the worst way. He should not be in the Hall Of Fame.
         Besides, it doesn't really matter anymore; and Jackson probably has more fans now than he would have if he had never been involved with the whole mess.
        As the game reeled from devastating gambling scandals, the healing process was already underway. As you can see above, a young man named Babe Ruth broke the existing record for home runs in a season, hitting 29 (the previous high was 27, by Ned Williamson in 1884). The dead-ball era was near its end, and the lively ball era was beginning. Ruth also went 9-5 as a pitcher, and is a logical choice as the MVP.

Defensive Positions (2B, 3B, SS, CA)
   AVGOBASLUABHIT DB TP HR RUN RBI BB SB OPS
2B E COLLINS CHI 319400405 51816519 7 4 87 80 6833 805
2B D PRATT NY 292342393 52715427 7 4 69 56 3622 735
SS R PECKINPAUGH NY305390404 45313820 2 7 89 33 5910 794
3B F BAKER NY 293346388 56716622 110 70 83 4413 734
CA W SCHANG BOS 306436373 33010116 3 0 43 55 7115 809
CA R SCHALK CHI 282367320 394111 9 3 0 57 34 5111 687
     

         Eddie Collins had joined the White Sox a few years before; this was his second pennant in Chicago. He and Jackson were the White Sox' best players, but they didn't get along too well. Collins was nicknamed "Cocky", and was a little arrogant. Collins was at the heart of a clique of players within the White Sox' clubhouse that outcast the illiterate Jackson. This is often given as the reason Jackson got mixed up with Chick Gandil and the other outcasts. Well, whatever. Collins was one of the best players in the league, and he never took any gamblers' money, so we can't be too critical.
        Roger Peckinpaugh had his best year as a hitter, and was a premier defensive player as well. He and Del Pratt and Frank Baker all played for the Yankees, who had finally emerged as a good team. Next year, they would buy Ruth from the Red Sox, and a year later would win their first pennant.

TOP FOUR 1919 AL STARGELL AWARD
Babe Ruth
Eddie Collins
Roger Peckinpaugh
Joe Jackson

1919
1918 1920
MAIN         NL     MAP