Ted Williams hit a home run in his last at bat, then retired after
the season ended. At age 42, the son-of-a-gun was still an awesome
hitter. Williams finished with a career .344 batting average, 521 home runs,
2654 hits, 2019 walks, and five years of military service.
Minnie Minoso was 37, and had his last big season. He hung on a few
more years, and finished with almost 2000 hits, remarkable
considering that he didn't reach the majors until he was 28. Minoso holds
a weird record, and not a particularly important one: he played in major league games
in five different decades. Eight years after retiring, Minnie came back in
1976 to bat eight times, and got one hit. Four years after that, in 1980, he
batted two more times, with no hits. Minoso tried to get into a game in 1991, but Commissioner Fay Vincent would not allow him to sign a contract. In 1993, at age 70, Minoso had one at bat in a game in the independent Northern League.
Maris and Mickey Mantle were teammates for the Yankees; Maris
won the MVP, finishing just three votes ahead of Mantle. It's a very
close call between the two of them; Maris had higher batting and slugging averages, plus more RBI, and won a Gold
Glove. Mantle had a higher OPS, more homers, scored more runs, and
produced more runs in total.
It's close, but I think Mantle deserves to be placed ahead of
Maris. For me, the clincher is in games played; Mantle missed only
two games, while Maris missed 19. That's a big difference. Maris, incidentally,
had a huge first half to the season; he hit 35 home runs in 99 games, on pace for 54. Maris clearly had put himself in a position to challenge
Ruth's homer mark, but a rib injury knocked him out of the lineup, and he hit only four home runs over the final third of the season. Roger would have to wait another
year to break the record.
I'm not sure who the best player of this infielders was... probably
one of Luis Aparicio, Brooks Robinson, or Earl Battey. Pete Runnels was good, too,
though he wasn't really a full-time second baseman; he also played a lot at first base.
Robinson finished third in the voting (not far behind Maris and
Mantle); that sounds reasonable to me. Minoso finished fourth in the
voting, which is also a good choice. My top four is almost the same
as the actual one, with only the top two candidates reversed.
Casey Stengel debuted as
a player in 1914 with the Brooklyn Dodgers. He frequently lamented that
he wasn't much of a player —
"for it is a game of skill" — but the truth
is that Casey was pretty good, and lasted for 14 years. His managerial
career began ingloriously; first, three years with the Dodgers, and three
losing seasons. Then came six years with the Braves, and six more losing
seasons. The Braves fired him midway through the 1943 season.
It was a surprise, then,
that Casey was hired by the Yankees in 1949. The Old Professor was 59
years old when he took over the Bombers; though he had had little success
as a manager, he had many golden nuggets of managerial philosophy, such
as "Good hitting will always stop good pitching, and vice-versa" and "The secret to
managing is to keep the guys who hate you away from the guys who are undecided."
Casey's first five years with the Yankees, 1949-53, all resulted in World
Series championships.
Casey was unlike any other manager
in baseball. He loved to platoon, and always had a bench full of quality
players. He used a five-man rotation, and never overworked his starting
pitchers; he used his bullpen more often than any other manager. Casey also supervised
the growth of Mickey Mantle into a superstar; if Mantle stayed out late
or broke the rules, teammates would stand and watch while the Old Man physically
assaulted the young stud. Casey was also quick to rid the team of any player
(such as Billy Martin) who might lead Mantle astray. According to Casey:
"Being with a woman never hurt no ballplayer; it's staying up all night
looking for one that does him in.
The Yankees won two more World
Series in 1956 and 1958. After winning the pennant this season, the Yankees faced the Pirates, and
lost; the fatal blow was a game-winning home run hit by Bill
Mazeroski. New York management, itching to fire manager Casey (now 70
years old), pulled the trigger after season on the grounds that Casey
was too old to be effective. In total, Stengel managed
the Yankees for 12 years; in that period, he won the pennant ten
times, as well as seven World Series championships.
Casey returned to New York
in 1962 as manager of the expansion Mets. The Mets lost 120 games that year,
and were arguably that worst team in baseball history. Stengel managed
them for three full seasons, trying to mold the young players into a team.
It wasn't easy; said Casey: "Can't anyone here play this game?" Some prospects
were better than others; Casey thought that young Ed Kranepool had a chance
to be a star, and added that "And Greg Goossen, he's only twenty, with a
chance in ten years of being thirty."
Stengel was fired for the final time
during the 1965 season; he left behind a legacy as one of the game's greatest
managers and most beloved clowns. He also left behind many memorable quotes,
including the ultimate managers' credo: "I couldna' done it without my players."