There are a lot of people, including myself, who believe that Lefty Grove is the greatest pitcher in baseball history. In terms of career greatness, I think only Walter Johnson and Cy Young compare. In terms of peak performance, only Johnson, Sandy Koufax, Pedro Martinez and maybe Roger Clemens, are really comparable. This was Grove's best year, and it was something to see.

1931 American League Pitchers
  WNLSGPGSCGSHSVIP HIT BB SO ERA
L GROVE PHI 31 441 30274 5289249 62175206
L GOMEZ NY 21 940 2617 1 3243206 85150267
G EARNSHAW PHI 21 743 3023 3 6282255 75152367
R WALBERG PHI 201244 3519 1 3291298109106374
W FERRELL CLE 221240 3527 2 3276276130123375
L BROWN WAS 151442 3215 1 0259256 79 79320
G CROWDER WAS 181144 2613 1 2234255 72 85388
B HADLEY WAS 111055 11 2 1 8180145 92124305
F MARBERRY WAS 16 445 2511 1 7219211 63 88345
     

1931 American League

Boston Red Sox
Chicago White Sox
Cleveland Indians
Detroit Tigers
New York Yankees
Philadelphia Athletics
St. Louis Browns
Washington Senators
         The Philadelphia Athletics won their third straight pennant, though they lost in the World Series to the Cardinals. Owner Connie Mack then ran out of money, and began to sell off his best players, including Grove. The Athletics eventually returned to the playoffs in 1971, a drought of 40 years.
         As for Grove...I think a 31-4 record speaks for itself. This was another big year for the hitters, so Grove's ERA is even more impressive than it looks. The previous year Grove was 28-5; that's a two year record of 59-9, which I think is the best two-year record ever. During his career, Grove won an astonishing nine ERA titles (the next best total is six). Even as an aging left-hander who had lost his fastball and was pitching in Fenway Park, he still won more ERA titles. In this survey, I've given Grove eight Cy Young Awards, tied with Johnson for the most of any pitcher.
         Lefty Gomez had his first great season. Gomez was really weird, and I'll talk about him later, but he was a hell of a pitcher. George Earnshaw was Grove's teammate with the Athletics; he didn't reach the majors until he was 28, but was a solid pitcher for several seasons.
         Rube Walberg also pitched for the Athletics. He was a decent pitcher for a long time; this was his best year. Walberg has almost the same numbers as Wes Ferrell; I'll give Walberg the slight edge, for pitching more innings and for playing with a champion.

TOP FOUR 1931 AL MATHEWSON AWARD
Lefty Grove
Lefty Gomez
George Earnshaw
Rube Walberg

1931
1930 1932
MAIN         NL     MAP