Thornton Lee pitched well every year for a long time but always got stuck with mediocre won-loss records. He pitched for the White Sox, a team that had some good pitchers but struggled badly to score runs. This year, Lee was outstanding, and had a great won-loss record, even though his team was last in the league in runs scored.

1941 American League Pitchers
  WNLSGPGSCGSHSVIP HIT BB SO ERA
T LEE CHI 221135 3430 3 1300258 92130237
B FELLER CLE 251344 40286 2343284194260315
D LEONARD WAS 181334 3319 4 0256271 54 91345
M RUSSO NY 141028 2717 3 1210195 87105309
L BENTON DET 15 638 14 7 1 7158130 65 63296
C WAGNER BOS 12 829 2512 3 0187175 85 51308
J MURPHY NY 8 335 0 0 015 77 68 40 29199
     

1941 American League

Boston Red Sox
Chicago White Sox
Cleveland Indians
Detroit Tigers
New York Yankees
Philadelphia Athletics
St. Louis Browns
Washington Senators
         Lee led the league in ERA by a wide margin, and was among the league leaders in everything else. I think he clearly has to rank as the best in the league this year. Next year, Lee went just 2-6, apparently missing time because of injury. The rest of his career was mostly a struggle, and he finished with a record of 117-124, which is too bad because he was a fine pitcher.
         This was Bob Feller's sixth season, and third consecutive one in which he had at least 24 wins. And he was 22 years old! He pitched a huge number of innings, and was easily the top strikeout pitcher in the game. He also walked a huge number of batters, which kept him from pitching as well as Lee, but he was still clearly the second-best pitcher in the league.
         After the season, Feller went off to war, and didn't return until the last month of 1945, missing almost four complete seasons. Despite missing all this time, Feller won 266 games in his career; you often here that the war cost Feller 300 wins, maybe even 400. That may be true, but I wonder. Feller lost his fastball when he was 30, then hung around for eight more years throwing junk and putting up .500 records. His managers let him throw an absurd number of innings when he was very young. If Feller hadn't gone to war, would he have won another 100 games, or would he have blown out his arm when he was 25? We'll never know, I guess.
         Johnny Murphy was won of the first pitchers who thrived in a relief role. This was probably Murphy's best year in the role; his ERA and won-loss record were both outstanding. Relievers at this time were usually failed starters, and Murphy seems to fit that description. His control was lousy, and he didn't strike anybody out. He pitched for a great Yankee team that won the World Series, and they probably helped his stats. He pitched well, but not well enough to merit Cy Young consideration.
         When you think of great Yankee pitchers, Marius Ugo Russo usually doesn't come to mind. But this year, in which the Yankees won the World Series and Joe DiMaggio had the 56 game hit streak, Russo was their best pitcher. This was the third of three terrific seasons he began his career with; afterwards he went off to war, and didn't win a game when he got back. He was another Yankee lefty in the Pennock-Gomez-Ford-Guidry-Pettitte mold, and probably could have been real good had things gone his way.

TOP FOUR 1941 AL MATHEWSON AWARD
Thornton Lee
Bob Feller
Dutch Leonard
Marius Russo

1941
1940 1942
MAIN         NL     MAP