Since the demise of the New York Yankees, the American League pennant had been won by some unlikely victors. First, Minnesota; then, Baltimore. And now... the Boston Red Sox? Yes, Boston surprised everyone, including themselves, and won their first pennant in 21 years. They had a rookie manager, Dick Williams. They had a Triple Crown winner, Carl Yastrzemski. And they had a Cy Young winner, in Jim Lonborg.

1967 American League Pitchers
  WNLSGPGSCGSHSVIP HIT BB SO ERA
J HORLEN CHI 19 735 35136 0258188 58103206
J LONBORG BOS 22 939 3915 2 0273228 83246316
G PETERS CHI 161138 3611 3 0260187 91215228
D CHANCE MIN 20 1441 3918 5 1284244 68220273
E WILSON DET 221139 3812 0 0264216 92184327
J MERRITT MIN 13 737 2811 4 0228196 30161253
S HARGAN CLE 141330 29156 0223180 72141262
S SEIBERT CLE 101234 26 7 1 4185136 54136238
T JOHN CHI 101331 29 96 0178143 47110247
M DRABOWSKY BAL 7 543 0 0 012 95 66 25 96160
     

1967 American League

Baltimore Orioles
Boston Red Sox
California Angels
Chicago White Sox
Cleveland Indians
Detroit Tigers
Kansas City Athletics
Minnesota Twins
New York Yankees
Washington Senators
        The Sox lost the World Series in seven games to the Cardinals, but it seemed a good bet at the time that they would have continued success. It never happened; in the off-season, Lonborg broke his leg skiing, and vanished almost as quickly as he had arrived (though he would eventually have a couple of good seasons with Philadelphia). Despite the presence of some good players, the team could never get over the top again. Dick Williams was fired, and won some championships with Oakland instead.
        As for Lonborg, he had an impressive season. His ERA is a little higher than the other guys, but remember, he pitched in Fenway Park. I don't think he was the best pitcher in the league, and he was a long way from Roger Clemens, but he was good.
        This was the first year that the AL gave out its own Cy Young Award. Lonborg won easily over Joel Horlen. But in the MVP balloting, Horlen received more support. Why? Horlen's team, the White Sox finished only three games out of first place. They had unbelievable pitching, led by Horlen and Gary Peters. Chicago was the only team with a staff ERA under 3.00, and it was 2.45. Their offense stunk, of course; only the Yankees(!) scored fewer runs. But I think Horlen was clearly the AL's best pitcher.
        I'm inclined to think that Peters, and maybe Dean Chance as well, might have been better than Lonborg. But I'll give Big Jim the benefit of the doubt, that it was a tough year pitching in Fenway Park. Oddly enough, all four pitchers- Horlen, Lonborg, Peters, Chance- slipped badly next year, and would not recover.

TOP FOUR 1967 AL MATHEWSON AWARD
Joel Horlen
Jim Lonborg
Gary Peters
Dean Chance

1967
1966 1968
MAIN         NL     MAP