Clemens had a losing season in 1996; though it was a disappointing
year, he ended it on a good note, pitching well down the stretch, and striking
out 20 batters in a game for the second time. After the joining the Blue Jays,
Clemens continued where he left off. He won his first eleven decisions, on his
way to perhaps the best season of his career. Clemens won the pitchers' Triple
Crown, leading the AL in wins, ERA, and strikeouts. His ERA was the third-lowest
in the AL since the DH rule began in 1973; only Ron Guidry in 1978 and Clemens
himself in 1990 have had lower ERAs.
Randy Johnson returned from serious back problems
to have a wonderful year. In many other years, it would have been the best
in the league, but he was not quite as good as Clemens. Johnson was 18-2 in
1995; in 1996 he was 5-0 in an injury-plagued season. From 1995-97, Johnson's
combined won-loss record was 43-6. Obviously, very few pitchers have ever reached
a level of performance equal to that of Randy Johnson in the late 1990's.
Brad Radke finished third in the Cy Young vote.
Radke was a very talented young pitcher who had his first big season; though
it is still his best to date, Radke has remained one of the better pitchers in
baseball. But I think that Yankee ace Andy Pettitte was better, with an ERA
a full run lower than Radke's. Like Radke, Pettitte is another young pitcher
who has yet to match his level of performance from this season.
Randy Myers actually led all pitchers in the
MVP vote, the idea being that he may not have been the best pitcher in the
league, but he was the most valuable. Maybe; Myers certainly had a terrific
year, but I prefer Mariano Rivera. More games, more innings, more wins, better
control. Myers has more saves and a slightly lower ERA. It's close, but I
will stick with Rivera, who had his first great season as a closer, and has
since emerged as the best in the league.