This is the season. Honus Wagner had one of those years, like Ruth in 1921 and Mantle in 1956 and Bonds in 2001 when he just towered over every other baseball player on the planet. At first glance, it doesn't look that special; a 957 OPS is awfully good but many players have done better. But this was the ultimate Year Of The Pitcher, when run scoring completely bottomed out; many pitchers allowed less than two runs per game. A 957 OPS would look good in 2001; in this season, it was beyond spectacular. Wagner was so much better than any other player in the league, that this season has to rate as one of the most dominant in baseball history.
This was Cubs' shortstop Joe Tinker's best season at the
plate. He is in the Hall Of Fame, alongside Honus Wagner. Obviously
there was a big difference between Tinker's best season and Wagner's
best season. Tinker was an outstanding defensive player, and was
immortalized in a poem along with teammates Johnny Evers and Frank
Chance. Tinker was also immortalized for another reason: a game between the Cubs and the Giants, in which the Cubs were saved by their shortstop's quick thinking.
After taking a year off to work on his acting, "Turkey" Mike Donlin came back
and had his last big season. He then disappeared for two years,
trying his hand at various theatrical projects, before returning as
a bit player in 1911.
One of Donlin's teammates was first baseman
Fred Tenney. Tenney had had a good career, but he was 36, and this was his
last good season. During the tight playoff race at the season's end, Tenney
was hurt, and the Giants needed a replacement; fortunately, they had a 19-year-old
kid named Fred Merkle who was highly touted. In a decisive game between the
Giants and Cubs, Merkle was on first in the ninth inning when Al Bridwell
knocked a game-winning hit. Merkle made it halfway to second base, then headed
for the dugout to avoid the rush of fans onto the field.
Merkle, of course, was still obligated to touch second base before joining the celebrations. The Cubs' intrepid double-play duo, Tinker and Evers, got hold of the ball, and beat Merkle to the bag . The umpire called Merkle out.
After the confusion, both teams claimed victory; finally, the NL President
ruled the game a tie, and the Giants lost their decisive win. They would
also lose the pennant when the Cubs won a deciding playoff game. In truth, Merkle
didn't do anything that most other players in the league would not have
done... but the "Merkle Boner" was born, and lives on to this day.