The surprise winner of the MVP this year was Steve Garvey. Before this season, Garvey had been nothing more than a part-time third baseman who was famous for throwing balls over the first baseman's head and into the stands. The Dodgers moved him to first, and things started to click. Garvey had 200 hits, 100 RBI, a Gold Glove, and the Dodgers led the National League in victories.

National League 1974
    AVG OBA SLG AB HIT DB TP HR RUN RBI BB SB OPS
1B S GARVEY LA 312346469 64220032 321 95111 31 5 811
LF W STARGELLPIT 301409537 50815337 425 90 96 87 0 944
RF R SMITHSTL 309394528 51716026 923 79100 71 4 917
LF R GARR ATL 353384503 606214241711 87 54 2826 886
LF L BROCK STL 306368381 63519425 7 3105 48 61118 749
RF R ZISK PIT 313386476 53616830317 75 100 651 862

LF P ROSE CIN 284388388 65218545 7 3110 51 1062 773
CF C CEDENO HOU 269338461 61016429526 95 102 6457 799
CF J WYNN LA 271393497 53514517 43210410810818 884
CF/1B A OLIVER PIT 321360475 617198381211 96 85 3310 832

2B J MORGAN CIN 293427494 512150313 22 107 67 12058 921
2B D CASH PHI 300352378 6872062611 2 89 58 4620 729
3B M SCHMIDT PHI 282398546 56816028 73610811610623 941
3B Da EVANS ATL 240381419 57113721 32599791264 800
SS D CONCEPCIONCIN 281337397 59416725 114 70 82 4441 732
CA J BENCH CIN 280365507 62117438 233108129 80 5 870
CA T SIMMONS STL 272331447 59916333 620 66103 47 0 771
     

         Garvey later became one of the biggest stars of the decade, recording six 200-hit seasons and five 100-RBI seasons. To be honest, though, I don't think he was ever an MVP-calibre player. He hit for good, not great batting averages (his career high was .319). He never had a .500 slugging percenage; he was a good (but not great) power hitter. He never came close to having a .400 on-base percentage; Garvey rarely walked, and consequently never scored a 100 runs in a season. Even in 1975, when Garvey hit .319 and batted 658 times, he scored only 85 runs.
        Garvey played for 19 seasons, had over 2500 hits and over 200 career homers. He was an All Star ten times, was consistent and reliable at the plate and he had a good defensive reputation. He was also regarded as a team leader; even after he left the Dodgers, he helped the Padres win their first pennant in 1984. Garvey also compiled an impressive consecutive-game streak, though an injury left him well short of Gehrig's record.
        Garvey's fans considered to be a modern-day Gehrig, and not just because of his durability. Garvey was a clean-cut, chisel-jawed icon, a throwback who planned to enter politics after his playing career ended. But soon after his retirement, Garvey's public image was shattered by revelations of his extra-marital affairs. Garvey fathered children with several different women, and his wife added to the scandal by writing a book about him.
        The runner-up in the vote was Lou Brock, who set a new single-season stolen base record. But this really wasn't one of Lou's best seasons with the bat; and though he set the steals record, he had to take more chances on the basepaths to do so and was thrown out 33 times. It was a remarkable accomplishment for a 35-year-old player, and overall he had a good, solid year for the Cardinals, but Lou can't be considered a strong MVP candidate this season.
        I think the best players in the league were two Cincinnati infielders, Joe Morgan and Johnny Bench. Bench finished fourth in the MVP vote, and Morgan eighth. For the life of me, I can't understand how anyone could not think that these two guys were the best in the league. Joe Morgan was probably the better player, and I'm choosing him as the MVP. There just aren't any flaws in his game. He hit for average, hit for power, drew walks, was a sensational base stealer, and a good defensive player. Bench was a great defensive catcher, and a durable power hitter. And the Reds had a great year.
        Morgan and Bench also had some stiff competition from Mike Schmidt, who had his first big year. Schmidt always had power, but had some trouble early in his career making contact with the ball (he hit only .196 the year before, despite playing almost full time). He made some adjustments, and had a big year. Schmidt was also the best defensive third baseman in the National League; this was recognized two years later when Schmidt won his first of ten Gold Gloves.

TOP FOUR 1974 NL STARGELL AWARD
Joe Morgan
Johnny Bench
Mike Schmidt
Willie Stargell

1974
1973 1975
MAIN         AL     MAP