The Cincinnati Reds won their first real World Series this year (their only other one had been in 1919, when the Black Sox junked the Series). The Reds didn't have a great offense, but were blessed with a wonderful pitching staff, led by Bucky Walters and Paul Derringer.

1940 National League Pitchers
  WNLSGPGSCGSHSVIP HIT BB SO ERA
B WALTERS CIN 221036 3629 3 0305241 92115248
C PASSEAU CHI 201346 3120 4 5281259 59124250
P DERRINGER CIN 201237 3726 3 0297280 48115306
F FITZSIMMONSBRO 16 220 1811 4 1134120 25 35282
L WARNEKE STL 161033 3117 1 0232235 47 85314
R SEWELL PIT 16 533 2314 2 1190169 67 60279
J TURNER CIN 14 724 2311 0 0187187 32 53289
K HIGBE PHI 14 1941 3620 1 1283242 121 137372
     

        Walters was a journeyman pitcher until 1939 when, at age thirty, he won 27 games. This year, he proved it wasn't a fluke, and dominated the NL for the second straight year. He continued to pitch well for most of the decade, and finished his career with 198 wins.
        The next best pitchers in the league were two lefties, Derringer and Claude Passeau. Though their numbers are similar, and Derringer pitched for a winner, I have to give the edge to Passeau. His ERA is more than half a run lower, and he picked up five saves as well.
        This was Derringer's last good season; he hung around a few more years without pitching very well, then retired with 223 wins. He was a survivor, had a 7-27 record in 1933, but stuck around to have four 20+ win seasons. He was quite similar to Tommy John, except he didn't pitch as long.
        There are a few pitchers who I could give the nod for the number four spot in the vote. Lon Warneke had another fine season, as did Rip Sewell and Jim Turner. Freddie Fitzsimmons didn't pitch as many innings as the other guys, but he pitched well, and you can't argue with a 16-2 record. Fitzsimmons was 39 years old, and was a big reason why the Dodgers finished in second place, despite the fact he pitched only once a week. "Fat Freddie" had one more good season, then faded away with 217 career wins.

TOP FOUR 1940 NL MATHEWSON AWARD
Bucky Walters
Claude Passeau
Paul Derringer
Freddie Fitzsimmons

1940
1939 1941
MAIN         AL     MAP