Mark Davis of the San Diego Padres won the Cy Young Award. Davis had debuted
with the Phillies in 1980, at age 19. He was a starting pitcher, and by age
24 had a career record of 17-37. His new team, the Giants, decided to move
him to the bullpen, where he pitched better; inexplicably, they then moved
him back to the starting rotation, where he again struggled. Finally, Davis
was dealt to the Padres, who needed a closer. Davis did the job magnificently
for three seasons, and this was his best one.
At the end of the season, Davis was 28 years
old, and a free agent. After winning the Cy Young Award, he signed a monster
contract with the Kansas City Royals. The signing was a disaster; Davis
pitched horribly for the Royals over the next three seasons, and never
again regained effectiveness. Not only was the Davis signing an expensive
bust, it was completely unnecessary; the Royals already had a great young
closer in Jeff Montgomery. A smart organization for many years, the Royals
spent their money horribly in the early 1990's, and have never really recovered
since then.
After his phenomenal season in 1988, Orel
Hershiser followed up with a season that was almost as good. But he wasn't
rewarded with many wins; the Dodgers this season had the worst offense in
the National League, and Hershiser got stuck with a mediocre record. Still,
I think that Orel was again clearly the best starting pitcher in the league.
It was Hershiser's last great season; in 1990 he started only four games, then
had Tommy John surgery on his arm. When he returned he continued to pitch
well, though not nearly as well as before.
Mike Scott was runner-up in the Cy Young
vote. He had a terrific year, but I think there were other pitchers who
were better. Joe Magrane was a big lefty, 6'6" tall. He didn't throw hard,
but he had good stuff; after leading the NL in ERA in 1988, he came back with
a big season this year. Magrane had a tough season in 1990, losing 17 games
despite pitching well; afterwards, he too required surgery on his arm,
and couldn't make a comeback.
Greg Maddux, you have probably heard of. "The
Professor" was just a young punk at this time, 23 years old. He had his
second straight outstanding season, and led the Cubs into the playoffs. Unlike
Hershiser and Magrane, Maddux stayed healthy. He pitched well the next two
seasons, then took a couple steps forward to become one of the greatest
pitchers ever, winning four straight Cy Young Awards at one point during the
1990's.