A rare case in which a pitcher with an inferior won-loss record won the award. The Arizona Diamondbacks, in only their second year of existence, won the West Division. They accomplished this feat by signing a number of high-priced free agents, the biggest of whom was the Big Unit, Randy Johnson. Johnson was the best pitcher in the NL, and challenged Nolan Ryan's strikeout record of 383... but didn't pick up as many wins as you would expect.

1999 National League Pitchers
  WNLSGPGSCGSHSVIP HIT BB SO ERA
R JOHNSONARI 1793535122 0272207 70364248
K MILLWOODATL 187333320 0228168 59205268
M HAMPTONHOU 224343432 0239206 101177290
G MADDUXATL 199333340 0219258 37136357
J LIMAHOU 2110353530 0246256 44187358
K BROWNLA 189353551 0252210 59221300
B WAGNERHOU 4166000 397535 23124157
A BENITEZNY 4377000 227840 41128185
S WILLIAMSONCIN 12762000 199354 43107241
     

1999 National League

Arizona Diamondbacks
Atlanta Braves
Chicago Cubs
Cincinnati Reds
Colorado Rockies
Florida Marlins
Houston Astros
Los Angeles Dodgers
Milwaukee Brewers
Montreal Expos
New York Mets
Philadelphia Phillies
Pittsburgh Pirates
San Diego Padres
San Francisco Giants
St. Louis Cardinals
         Mike Hampton of the Astros had a monster year, and has a good argument for deserving the award. His won-loss record was outstanding, and his ERA wasn't too much higher than Johnson's (though Hampton was helped by the Astrodome, a pitcher's park). But Johnson got a lot of attention for his losses; one of them was a 1-0 loss to a no-hitter by Jose Jimenez. Despite having a potent offense, the Diamondbacks couldn't muster a lot of support for their big man. But he won the award anyway, and deserved it.
         Next I'll take Hampton, who also led the Astros to a division title. He is followed by Kevin Millwood of the Braves. At this writing, most of these pitchers are still early in their careers. This was Millwood's second full season, and it was outstanding in every respect; he was even tougher to hit than Johnson! Millwood was the best pitcher on an Atlanta staff that included several great veterans, and threw a one-hitter in the playoffs, helping the Braves win the pennant.
        Aside from Johnson, veterans who had impressive seasons included Greg Maddux and Kevin Brown. Maddux had an off-year by his own standards, but was still very good. Brown signed a huge contract with the Dodgers before the season, and took some criticism when the team had a terrible year. But make no mistake, Brown had a great year.
        In the fourth spot, however, I will take a reliever, Billy Wagner of the Astros. Wagner was the best closer in the NL this season; his strikeout rate was phenomenal, he was almost impossible to hit, and he had very good control, in what was a completely dominant season.

TOP FOUR 1999 NL MATHEWSON AWARD
Randy Johnson
Mike Hampton
Kevin Millwood
Billy Wagner

1999
1998 2000
MAIN         AL     MAP